Donna Tartt's The Secret History (often referred to as God of the Woods due to its central motif) leaves readers grappling with the ambiguous fate of Barbara Hawke. While the novel doesn't explicitly detail what precisely happened to her, the clues scattered throughout the narrative paint a disturbing and ultimately tragic picture. This ambiguity is, of course, part of the novel's power, fueling ongoing discussions and interpretations. Let's delve into the evidence and explore the most likely scenarios surrounding Barbara's demise.
What clues suggest foul play?
The disappearance and presumed death of Barbara Hawke is the inciting incident of The Secret History. The initial assumption is that she fell to her death during a drunken, unsupervised excursion. However, several factors strongly suggest otherwise:
-
The lack of a body: This is a classic element of mystery fiction, suggesting a deliberate attempt to conceal the crime. The absence of any concrete evidence of an accidental fall raises suspicion.
-
Henry's disturbing behavior: Henry Winter's unsettling calm and control in the aftermath of Barbara's disappearance, coupled with his manipulative nature and penchant for violence, makes him the prime suspect. His subsequent actions solidify this suspicion.
-
The inconsistencies in the accounts: The initial accounts given by the group of students are riddled with inconsistencies and evasions. This deliberate obfuscation points towards a concerted effort to cover up their involvement.
-
The ritualistic aspects: The novel’s focus on the Bacchic rituals and the group's descent into violence hints that Barbara’s death might be intertwined with their secretive practices. The secretive nature of the group suggests they might have covered up something far more sinister than an accident.
Was Barbara murdered? If so, who was responsible?
The prevailing interpretation among readers is that Barbara was murdered, likely by the group of Classics students, with Henry Winter as the driving force. The motive could be linked to several factors:
-
Accidental Death Covered Up: A possible interpretation suggests that Barbara’s death was initially accidental, perhaps during one of their intoxicated rituals. However, the group, overwhelmed by panic and driven by their shared secrets and pact of silence, decided to cover it up, concealing her body and fabricating a story.
-
Intentional Murder: A more sinister theory suggests that Barbara's death was a deliberate act, orchestrated by Henry, motivated by jealousy, obsession, or a desperate attempt to maintain the group's exclusive bond. Her presence threatened their carefully cultivated world.
-
Multiple Conspirators: It's possible that more than one member participated in the cover-up or the act itself, making it difficult to pinpoint a sole perpetrator. The close-knit nature of the group and their unwavering loyalty to each other makes it plausible that they all, to some degree, participated in concealing the truth.
Could Barbara have faked her death?
While a less likely scenario, the possibility of Barbara faking her own death and escaping cannot be entirely dismissed. However, the lack of any contact from her afterwards, along with the intensity of the group's actions to cover up her disappearance, makes this interpretation significantly less probable. The novel offers no evidence to support this theory.
What ultimately happened to Barbara? A Conclusion
The ambiguity surrounding Barbara's fate is intentional. Tartt leaves it open to interpretation, allowing readers to draw their own conclusions based on the subtle hints and clues provided throughout the novel. While the specifics remain shrouded in mystery, the overwhelming evidence suggests Barbara died violently, likely at the hands of the group, with Henry Winter playing a central, if not sole, role. The tragedy of Barbara's fate serves as a powerful reminder of the devastating consequences of secrecy, obsession, and the corrosive effects of unchecked power within a close-knit group.
